DRAM price-fixing lawsuit — case proceeds, no finding yet
On November 14, 2026, US District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California refused to dismiss a proposed class action accusing Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron of conspiring to restrict conventional DRAM supply. She held that, if the facts alleged are true, an agreement is plausible. The order does not find that collusion happened; it sends the case on to evidence gathering. The three companies must answer by December 7, 2026, and the first case management conference is set for January 12, 2027. The court accepted in part the argument that shifting output to HBM cannot by itself imply collusion, but gave weight to DDR4 wind-down announcements made within three months of each other and to nearly identical customer-vetting questions introduced in January 2026. A similar suit covering 2016 to 2018 was dismissed, and that dismissal was affirmed on appeal in 2022
The three lines
- The ruling — motion to dismiss denied on November 14, 2026. A Sherman Act Section 1 conspiracy is plausibly alleged; liability is not decided. Answers due December 7; first case management conference January 12, 2027
- The reasoning — the HBM shift alone was not enough, but the court weighed April-June 2025 DDR4 wind-down announcements, refusals of long-term conventional DRAM deals, Micron's exit from Crucial and look-alike customer vetting in January 2026
- The precedents — a suit over 2016-2018 was dismissed in 2019 and affirmed in March 2022. The 1998-2002 cartel was a US criminal case: Samsung was fined $300 million and Hynix $185 million
Key questions
- DRAM price-fixing lawsuit ruling
- **A US court on November 14, 2026 denied the motion by Samsung, SK hynix and Micron to dismiss. The order lets the case continue; it does not find collusion.** | Item | Detail | |---|---| | Court and judge | Northern District of California, Judge Noël Wise | | Filed | June 25, 2026, by 17 consumers and small businesses | | Defendants | Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, Micron | | Claim | Conspiracy to restrict conventional DRAM supply from October 2022 | | Order | Motion to dismiss denied, November 14, 2026 | | Next dates | Answers December 7; case management conference January 12, 2027 |
- what does denying a motion to dismiss mean
- **At this stage a court assumes the complaint's facts are true and asks only whether they plausibly describe a violation. No evidence has been examined.** | Stage | What the court looks at | Status here | |---|---|---| | Motion to dismiss | Is a conspiracy plausible on the complaint alone | Cleared November 14, 2026 | | Discovery | Exchange of internal emails, minutes and data | Scope to be discussed January 12, 2027 | | Class certification | Can buyers be treated as one class | Not yet | | Summary judgment | Does the evidence require a trial | Not yet | | Trial or settlement | Did collusion actually occur | Not yet |
- Samsung SK hynix Micron DRAM cartel history
- **There are two precedents. The 1998-2002 conspiracy was prosecuted by the US Justice Department and ended in fines. A civil suit over 2016-2018 was dismissed.** | Case | Type | Outcome | |---|---|---| | 1998-2002 DRAM cartel | US criminal case | Samsung $300 million, Hynix $185 million, Infineon $160 million in fines; Micron received immunity for reporting | | Alleged 2016-2018 supply restraint | Civil class action | Dismissed September 2019; affirmed March 7, 2022 | | Alleged supply restraint from October 2022 | Civil class action | Motion to dismiss denied November 14, 2026; ongoing |
A US court has refused to end a class action accusing the world's three main memory makers of fixing DRAM prices. On November 14, 2026, Judge Noël Wise of the US District Court for the Northern District of California denied a joint motion to dismiss filed by Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron. Her conclusion was that if the plaintiffs' factual claims are true, an agreement to restrict the supply of conventional DRAM is plausible. The three companies must file answers by December 7, 2026, and the first case management conference is set for January 12, 2027.
The order is not a finding that collusion took place. It means the case has cleared the stage at which a court decides, on the complaint alone, whether to end it. No evidence has been examined. This article sets out what the court relied on, what a motion to dismiss tests and what comes after it, how this case differs from two earlier ones involving the same companies, and what risk remains for the two South Korean defendants, which together with Micron supply almost all of the world's DRAM. The text of the order could not be opened; what follows cross-checks reports that describe it.
1. What the court looked at — the HBM shift was not enough, the surrounding conduct was
The suit was filed on June 25, 2026 by 17 US consumers and small businesses. South Korean coverage describes them as 14 consumers and three small PC builders or distributors. They are indirect purchasers: they bought PCs, laptops and memory kits, not chips from the makers. The core claim is that the three companies conspired from October 2022 to restrict conventional DRAM supply, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The three held more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025.
The plaintiffs point to four strands of conduct: production cuts between October 2022 and April 2023, a shift of capacity to high-bandwidth memory (HBM, the stacked memory used with AI accelerators), DDR4 wind-down plans announced within three months of each other, and a failure to add capacity while prices soared. The companies replied that the suit repeats one already dismissed. They also argued that in a concentrated market, rivals watch each other like hawks and end up making similar decisions. The judge took up the phrase and wrote that the conduct alleged is "more akin to hawks flying in formation."
| Conduct alleged | The court's view, as reported |
|---|---|
| Shift of capacity to HBM | Not enough by itself to infer collusion. The court accepted in part that HBM was simply the more profitable product |
| Production cuts, October 2022 to April 2023 | SK hynix and Micron first, Samsung about four and a half months later. Not so long a gap that it defeats a parallel-conduct claim at this stage |
| DDR4 wind-down announcements, April to June 2025 | All three announced within one quarter while DDR4 was still widely used. The court did not accept that these were independent moves to DDR5 |
| Long-term HBM contracts, refusals of long-term conventional DRAM deals, Micron's exit from Crucial | Weighed together as supporting a plausible inference of prior coordination |
| Nearly identical customer-vetting questions introduced in January 2026 | Found to support the inference of a conspiracy strongly |
| End of DDR3 production | Set aside as not parallel (confirmed in one source only) |
The table shows that the court did not accept the complaint whole. It gave little weight to the most visible fact, the move to HBM, because moving to a more profitable product is a decision a company can make alone. The weight fell on conduct that is harder to explain as a solo decision: turning down long-term contracts with large customers for a product whose price was rising, and introducing look-alike procedures in the same month asking customers about their end users and order volumes.
The court has not adopted any figure for how far prices rose. The plaintiffs' numbers are quoted differently across reports: up to 500% in a year, about 697% over 18 months, and a 171.8% rise in contract prices in the year through the third quarter of 2025. These cover different periods and measures.
2. What a motion to dismiss tests — the Twombly standard and the road ahead
In US civil procedure a defendant can ask the court to dismiss before filing an answer. The argument is that even if everything in the complaint is true, it does not amount to a violation. At this stage the court does not look at evidence. It assumes the facts alleged are true and asks whether they plausibly describe an unlawful agreement.
For conspiracy claims, that threshold was set by the US Supreme Court's 2007 decision in Bell Atlantic v. Twombly. Parallel conduct, meaning competitors acting alike at about the same time, is not enough to allege an agreement. In a market with few sellers, companies often follow each other without agreeing to, and that is lawful. A plaintiff has to add circumstances that an agreement explains better than independent judgment does. Lawyers call these plus factors.
| Stage | What happens | Status in this case |
|---|---|---|
| Motion to dismiss | Court decides whether a conspiracy is plausible on the complaint alone | Plaintiffs cleared it on November 14, 2026 |
| Answer | Defendants respond to each allegation | Due December 7, 2026 |
| Case management conference | Schedule and scope of discovery are set | January 12, 2027 |
| Discovery | Internal documents produced, executives deposed | Not started |
| Class certification | Court decides whether buyers can sue as one class | Not started |
| Summary judgment | Court decides whether the evidence requires a trial | Not started |
| Trial or settlement | Whether collusion actually occurred is decided | Not started |
What the order changes is that discovery can begin. The plaintiffs can now demand internal material from the three companies. TrendForce News reported that internal emails, management meeting records, customer allocation criteria and capacity investment documents may be covered. Whether an agreement existed will be decided from that material. Between clearing the threshold and winning lie two further hurdles, class certification and summary judgment, and private antitrust cases in the United States commonly take years to reach them.
3. Two precedents — why the 2018 suit failed and what is different now
The centre of the defence was the 2018 suit. Filed in April 2018, it alleged that the three companies jointly held back DRAM supply in 2016 to 2018. Judge Jeffrey White of the same court dismissed the complaint on September 3, 2019, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed on March 7, 2022. The appeals court held that the plaintiffs had alleged parallel conduct but nothing more. Capital spending cuts announced within about two months of each other could be a matter of following the market leader, and statements on earnings calls or attendance at industry meetings were consistent with acting independently. The one factor it found to support the plaintiffs was the companies' earlier price-fixing convictions.
| 1998-2002 cartel | 2016-2018 suit | Suit over conduct from October 2022 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | US Justice Department criminal case | Civil class action | Civil class action |
| Core evidence or allegations | Leniency application and guilty pleas | Simultaneous cuts, public statements, past record | Cuts, DDR4 wind-down, refused long-term deals, customer vetting |
| Outcome | Fines of $300 million for Samsung, $185 million for Hynix, $160 million for Infineon | Dismissed 2019; affirmed 2022 | Motion to dismiss denied; ongoing |
| Micron | Immunity for reporting the cartel | Defendant; prevailed | Defendant |
Judge Wise held that the new complaint is not a repeat of the 2018 suit, citing added allegations about long-term HBM supply deals, changes in conventional DRAM contracting and customer screening, according to PYMNTS. What the courts examined in the earlier case was mostly public statements and investment cuts. This complaint includes specific dealings with customers. That is a difference between two complaints. Whether it is also a difference in evidence is not yet known to anyone outside the companies.
The 1998-2002 case was of a different kind. The Justice Department investigated and the companies pleaded guilty. Samsung agreed in October 2005 to a $300 million fine, at the time the second largest in a US criminal antitrust case. Executives served prison terms, and Micron avoided prosecution by reporting the cartel first. The European Union followed in 2010 with fines of more than 331 million euros on nine makers. The present case is a civil suit brought by buyers, not a government investigation. It carries no criminal penalties, and the leniency mechanism that shaped the earlier case does not apply in the same way.
4. Share prices and the risk left for the Korean makers
On November 16, 2026, the first trading day after the order, Micron shares fell nearly 7% in early New York trading and were reported to close at $719.02, down 7.6%. The fall cannot be read as a reaction to the lawsuit alone. The Nasdaq Composite lost 2.5% the same day, and 33 of 34 other chip companies worth $2 billion or more also fell, according to Trefis. It was a day of broad selling in AI-linked stocks ahead of Nvidia's results. In Seoul, Samsung Electronics and SK hynix fell sharply during the session on foreign selling, Economist Korea reported. Their closing moves were not confirmed.
Three kinds of risk remain for the Korean companies.
First, internal records go before a court. Once discovery begins, the process behind production cuts and product discontinuations, and the criteria for dividing supply among customers, pass to the plaintiffs' lawyers. With memory in short supply and most 2027 volume reported as already contracted, allocation is the centre of the sales operation. Economist Korea noted that judicial scrutiny of those criteria could weigh on negotiations with customers. The court has not ordered any change to HBM production or to how supply is allocated.
Second, there is no number for the money yet. The complaint is reported not to specify an amount. US antitrust law allows treble damages, but these plaintiffs are indirect purchasers, who must generally rely on state law for damages. The size of any exposure depends on how broad a class is certified. Estimates of damages made at this stage have no basis.
Third, the case can spread. A US court finding a conspiracy claim plausible gives other groups of buyers, and regulators elsewhere, a reason to look. In the 2000s the US investigation was followed by EU fines. No report was found that the Justice Department or any other competition authority has opened an inquiry related to this case.
5. What remains open and what is not confirmed
| Open question | Status |
|---|---|
| Text of the order | Not opened. Five reports were cross-checked |
| Whether an agreement existed | Never decided. A matter for discovery and after |
| Size of the price increase | 500%, 697% and 171.8% are all quoted. All are allegations over different periods |
| Exclusion of the DDR3 allegations | Confirmed in one source only |
| Scope and amount of the claim | Reported as unspecified. A five-state limit on damages was not confirmed in an opened source |
| The companies' formal position | No statement found. Only the arguments in the motion were reported |
| Scope of discovery | To be discussed at the January 12, 2027 conference |
| Effect on Korean share prices | Only an intraday report for November 16, 2026. Closes not confirmed |
| Any government inquiry | No report found |
| Case number | Two versions appear. Not given here |
The order settles one fact: the plaintiffs are past the first threshold. The court said moving to HBM is hard to fault in itself, and also said the claim that the three companies' dealings in conventional DRAM were too alike to be coincidence deserves a hearing. The next dates to check are December 7, 2026, when answers are due, and January 12, 2027, when the case management conference is held.
Earlier coverage gives the background. How memory prices move South Korea's exports is in the September 7, 2026 article "What a memory supercycle is." How HBM differs from conventional DRAM is in the August 1, 2026 article "HBM explained," and how South Korea's own competition regulator calculates fines is in the August 7, 2026 article "How Korean antitrust fines are calculated." The next generation of conventional DRAM technology is covered in a separate article on 3D DRAM published the same day, November 20, 2026.
Sources
- TrendForce News — U.S. Judge Rejects Samsung, SK hynix, Micron's DRAM Price-Fixing Dismissal Bid, Citing Plausible Collusion (2026-11-16)
- Yonhap via Korean Center — US court denies Samsung, SK hynix bid to halt collusion suit (2026-11-16, Korean)
- Hardware Busters — summary of the Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics order (2026-11-15)
- PYMNTS (CPI) — Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Lose Bid to Dismiss US DRAM Antitrust Suit (2026-11-16)
- Yahoo Finance (GuruFocus) — Micron Stocks Sink Nearly 7% (2026-11-16)
- DigitalToday — Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix face U.S. D-RAM collusion lawsuit (2026-11-16)
- Economist Korea — The sudden DRAM collusion claim: how large is the legal risk? (2026-11-16, Korean)
- Trefis — Why Did Micron Stock Fall Nearly 8%? (2026-11-17)
- IBTimes Australia — Micron Stock Sinks Below $740 as AI Chip Selloff, DRAM Price-Fixing Lawsuit Hammer Memory Giant on Monday (2026-11-16)
- California Lawyers Association — Northern District of California Dismisses Price-Fixing Class Action Brought by Indirect Purchasers of DRAM (2020-01-07)
- Paul, Weiss — Ninth Circuit Analyzes Parallel Conduct Allegations and Does Not Find Something More (2022-03-09)
- CFO.com — Samsung Fined $300 Million for Price Fix (2005-10-14)
- Wikipedia — DRAM price fixing scandal